diff --git a/frontend-react/src/components/plus/SummaryLists.js b/frontend-react/src/components/plus/SummaryLists.js
index 9fcf87a5d..1bb58a731 100644
--- a/frontend-react/src/components/plus/SummaryLists.js
+++ b/frontend-react/src/components/plus/SummaryLists.js
@@ -37,7 +37,6 @@ const summaryMap = summary => {
 }
 
 const SummaryLists = ({ summaries }) => {
-  console.log("summaries", summaries)
   const members = []
   const suggested = []
 
diff --git a/frontend-react/src/components/plus/VotingHistory.js b/frontend-react/src/components/plus/VotingHistory.js
index 19de169de..9614a1243 100644
--- a/frontend-react/src/components/plus/VotingHistory.js
+++ b/frontend-react/src/components/plus/VotingHistory.js
@@ -20,7 +20,14 @@ const VotingHistory = () => {
   } = useQuery(userLean)
 
   useEffect(() => {
-    if (loading || error || userQueryLoading || userQueryError) return
+    if (
+      loading ||
+      error ||
+      userQueryLoading ||
+      userQueryError ||
+      !data.summaries
+    )
+      return
 
     const monthsYears = data.summaries.reduce(
       (acc, cur) => {
@@ -48,12 +55,12 @@ const VotingHistory = () => {
     setMonthChoices(monthsYears)
   }, [data, loading, error, userQueryLoading, userQueryError, userData])
 
+  if (!loading && !data.summaries) return <Redirect to="/access" />
   if (loading || userQueryLoading || monthChoices.length === 0)
     return <Loading />
   if (error) return <Error errorMessage={error.message} />
   if (userQueryError) return <Error errorMessage={userQueryError.message} />
   if (!userData.user) return <Redirect to="/access" />
-  if (!data.summaries) return <Redirect to="/404" />
 
   const parts = forms.monthYear.split(" ")
   const month = months.indexOf(parts[0])